SD Clubs - CHUG, QUAFF, Society of Barley Engineers - any opinions?

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Au111

Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2010
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Location
SanDiego
Considering finding a club for the usual (talking about brewing, sharing beers) and learning a bit more about scaling up to a larger system than I currently have.

Is one of the clubs more active than the others? More welcoming? More experienced? It's hard to tell from the websites.

I'm not looking to promote trash talk - just curious how these groups differ, if at all.

Cheers!
 
Thanks for the welcome. I'm in north county, coastal (in the beer dead zone we have around here), but "have beer, will travel."
 
QUAFF is the most active and experienced. I know that some of the other clubs were started by people who didn't care for QUAFF but that has happened in every city with a long standing club.
 
QUAFF is the most active and experienced. I know that some of the other clubs were started by people who didn't care for QUAFF but that has happened in every city with a long standing club.

Well, sure. I mean it happens with everything. The day CHUG becomes a long standing club is the day I pull the plug on it.

I started CHUG last year just to enter a competition that was club only. Now we have occasional outings and I would really like to get more into actual brewing events. I guess it really all depends on what you're looking to get out of a club. We have a site, can answer anyone's questions, I have a standing invitation to teach anyone all grain brewing, and I know a few things.

QUAFF will provide you with all that, but you get to pay dues and hang out with old dudes with mustaches who don't understand jokes. There are exceptions, but I just don't find myself being so serious.

I know some people in Foam on the Brain and they're nice. Not sure I know any Barley Engineers.

I'd say that there will be at least one person in any group that could answer all your questions. You're welcome to check us out. If you're a ****** or not a good fit in regards to personality, we fully expect you to realize this and not come back. We're not trying to be the biggest or the best. We're all just friends.

Edit: Most of our meetings (all) are in the central area of San Diego. Hamilton's and Blind Lady have been the winners so far.
 
Well, sure. I mean it happens with everything. The day CHUG becomes a long standing club is the day I pull the plug on it.

I started CHUG last year just to enter a competition that was club only. Now we have occasional outings and I would really like to get more into actual brewing events. I guess it really all depends on what you're looking to get out of a club. We have a site, can answer anyone's questions, I have a standing invitation to teach anyone all grain brewing, and I know a few things.

QUAFF will provide you with all that, but you get to pay dues and hang out with old dudes with mustaches who don't understand jokes. There are exceptions, but I just don't find myself being so serious.

I know some people in Foam on the Brain and they're nice. Not sure I know any Barley Engineers.

I'd say that there will be at least one person in any group that could answer all your questions. You're welcome to check us out. If you're a ****** or not a good fit in regards to personality, we fully expect you to realize this and not come back. We're not trying to be the biggest or the best. We're all just friends.

Edit: Most of our meetings (all) are in the central area of San Diego. Hamilton's and Blind Lady have been the winners so far.

I happily travel down to Blind Lady every now and again. Hmm, maybe today will be an 'again'...

Thanks!
 
Well, sure. I mean it happens with everything. The day CHUG becomes a long standing club is the day I pull the plug on it.

I started CHUG last year just to enter a competition that was club only. Now we have occasional outings and I would really like to get more into actual brewing events. I guess it really all depends on what you're looking to get out of a club. We have a site, can answer anyone's questions, I have a standing invitation to teach anyone all grain brewing, and I know a few things.

QUAFF will provide you with all that, but you get to pay dues and hang out with old dudes with mustaches who don't understand jokes. There are exceptions, but I just don't find myself being so serious.

I know some people in Foam on the Brain and they're nice. Not sure I know any Barley Engineers.

I'd say that there will be at least one person in any group that could answer all your questions. You're welcome to check us out. If you're a ****** or not a good fit in regards to personality, we fully expect you to realize this and not come back. We're not trying to be the biggest or the best. We're all just friends.

Edit: Most of our meetings (all) are in the central area of San Diego. Hamilton's and Blind Lady have been the winners so far.

What part of town do you live in?

I definitely don't mind driving out to BLAH......but I'm in east county
 
I'm a member of QUAFF, Barley Literates and CHUG.

QUAFF is massive. If you want to bring a beer to share plan on bringing 2 gallons for everyone to get a taste. The members are extremely helpful and will help you brew your beer to win competitions. They routinely sponsor tastings where judges will advise you on how to improve your beers, ciders, and meads. And they are currently sponsoring a BJCP training group. I attend 3-4 meetings per year.

Barley Literates is a much smaller group. 2-3 12oz bottles will give everyone there a taste of your beer. Being a smaller group it is much easier to get to know people and hold round table discussions. I attend the monthly meetings regularly.

And CHUG has no ``official'' membership. They hold occasional meetings when the mood strikes the group. Unfortunately I have not been able to attend a single one yet as I've been out of town for each and every one of them.

Joining QUAFF, Barley Literates, Foam on the Brain, or the Society of Barley Engineers will get you a 10% discount at most of the local home brew shops.
 
I'm a member of QUAFF, Barley Literates and CHUG.

QUAFF is massive. If you want to bring a beer to share plan on bringing 2 gallons for everyone to get a taste. The members are extremely helpful and will help you brew your beer to win competitions. They routinely sponsor tastings where judges will advise you on how to improve your beers, ciders, and meads. And they are currently sponsoring a BJCP training group. I attend 3-4 meetings per year.

Barley Literates is a much smaller group. 2-3 12oz bottles will give everyone there a taste of your beer. Being a smaller group it is much easier to get to know people and hold round table discussions. I attend the monthly meetings regularly.

And CHUG has no ``official'' membership. They hold occasional meetings when the mood strikes the group. Unfortunately I have not been able to attend a single one yet as I've been out of town for each and every one of them.

Joining QUAFF, Barley Literates, Foam on the Brain, or the Society of Barley Engineers will get you a 10% discount at most of the local home brew shops.

You can get 10% off at HBM and HBG if you tell them you're with us, too. Any club gets a club discount.
 
San Diego has a great selection of homebrew clubs, and nearly anyone should be able to find a club that suits them. Which is best for you will depend on what you are looking for and where you live. Similar discounts should be available at local shops with membership in any of these clubs.

I am actively involved in 3 of the local clubs: QUAFF, Society of Barley Engineers, and North County Homebrewers, so I can comment on these three. I don't have anything bad to say about any of them and they all serve different purposes for me.

QUAFF (meets in Mission Valley) is a huge, well-known, and long-standing club. Many of the best professional brewers in the SD area got there start in QUAFF and most are still members. Joining QUAFF is a great way to get well-connected in the SD beer community, both with homebrewers and pros. QUAFF has something on the order of 300+ members, with about 120 attending typical meetings. The guest speakers at monthly meetings are often well-respected professional brewers and sometimes bring really special beers to share. Beer sharing can be somewhat difficult with such large meetings. 2 half-gallon growlers is about the minimum to share with the entire meeting and it can be hard to get good comments with such a large group. If you bring less beer, just share with your table. The special events (holiday party, camping, oktoberfest, padres tailgate party, st pat's party, big brew day, etc) are my favorite part about QUAFF, these are a lot of fun and are an opportunity to really get to know some of the outstanding brewers in QUAFF. Even if the meetings aren't your thing, QUAFF membership might be worthwhile for the special events alone. It can be hard to get to know a large percentage of the QUAFF membership, but you will find it worthwhile if you take the time to get to know many of the members personally at events. The mailing list is very active and can be a great resource for learning, asking questions, and buying/selling equipment.

Society of Barley Engineers (meets at Stone, Escondido) is a much smaller, but well-organized club that holds formal meetings with featured topics. Because of its smaller size, the club tends to be a bit more tight-knit with most members knowing each other. Typical meeting attendance is about 35, and two 22oz bottles will make it around the room. Because less beer is required lots of beers are shared and members share their best beers. I personally share far more beers with SBE than QUAFF, because I am not usually willing to give away 2 growlers of my best beers in a single night. SBE doesn't do as many big events, but has some special meetings like beer and cheese pairings at local breweries. Most of the featured speakers are members, but a few meetings each year feature an outside guest speaker. The meetings are a much more intimate setting than QUAFF and I find it easier to pay attention to the speakers. The club also provides commercial examples of styles for most of the meetings, which makes the presentations a lot more meaningful. I'd say that in terms of monthly meetings, I probably learn the most from SBE out of all the clubs, due to the combination of the focused meeting topics, smaller and quieter setting, and useful comments on my shared homebrews. Several members are in both QUAFF and SBE, but seem to be more active with SBE (in terms of meeting attendance and beer sharing) because the meetings are smaller.

North County Homebrewers (meet at various north county locations) is a fun and casual club, and has found it's niche as being more of a social group than the other clubs that have sit-down meetings. Events are held at local breweries and at members' houses, with the location changing each month. A bar is set up for members to serve kegs at all meetings and there is almost always food, either provided by the club or potluck. There are rarely featured topics and the business portion is a quick stand-up meeting lasting about 20-30 minutes. The real value in NCHA is the opportunity to socialize and talk beer with other brewers. I find that I learn quite a bit just through the casual brewing conversations that come up. These meetings can be very valuable for getting good evaluations, because you can go around and serve your beer to people while soliciting comments, rather than passing it around the room at a sit-down meeting.

Whichever club(s) you choose, I'm sure you won't regret joining the great homebrew community and getting to know more brewers in the area. All of the clubs are glad to have prospective members come by for a meeting or two without officially joining, so you can certainly try them all out before you decide.
 
My wife Beth and I just hosted the first meeting of a new craft beer/homebrewers club in North Park, we had 10 people come over with a bottle or two of "something interesting" and it went really well! We knew everyone who came, but they didn't all know each other so it was pretty awesome introducing kindred spirits. We are planning monthly meetings and brewery outings. We have some friends who work at some of the good beer spots around here and are trying to organize some beer dinners in the near future. If any of you guys are interested in meeting up/hanging out shoot me a message because we are always looking to expand our circle of friends with similar interests!

Beth has a food blog and did a much better review of the evening than I just did if you'd like to see a list of beers we consumed http://www.thedelightedbite.blogspot.com/
 
Back
Top