Something WAY more important then smoking

Our smoking poll is now approaching 2 months old, and IMHO we have beaten that dead horse WAY too long. So let us now discuss something that is much more important . . . .

Cake or Pie?

Pie! Pie! Pie!

Pecan Pie!

Uh, I'm a sucker for a good pumpkin pie, but cake includes cheesecake and NOTHING is better than that.

Plus my wife makes THE best pumpkin cheesecake in the world, so I have the best of both worlds.

Dude said:

Uh, I'm a sucker for a good pumpkin pie, but cake includes cheesecake and NOTHING is better than that.

Plus my wife makes THE best pumpkin cheesecake in the world, so I have the best of both worlds.

Click to expand...

I diagree about cheesecake actually being a cake. I would argue that it is closer to a pie, despite what the name might advertise.

Hmmm... perhaps a thread to decide if cheesecake is more like a cake or more like a pie?

-walker

pie, pie, i love pie, me oh my!

apple, pecan, peach, key lime....

Walker said:

I diagree about cheesecake actually being a cake. I would argue that it is closer to a pie, despite what the name might advertise.


-walker

Click to expand...

Nahhh, I've had cheese pie, it sucks. And I'm from Wisconsin.

Cake!

I can only stand about three kinds of pie: pumpkin, raspberry, and key lime. Others are nasty!

i forgot to add sweet potato pie!!!!!! and pumpkin, and chess, and lemon, and COCONUT CREAM!!!

All I can think of when viewing this thread is the obese chick on Deuce Bigalow...
Cakes and pies, cakes and pies!!!!!!!!!

Dude said:

All I can think of when viewing this thread is the obese chick on Deuce Bigalow...
Cakes and pies, cakes and pies!!!!!!!!!

Click to expand...

i thought it was "beans 'n franks, beans 'n franks"...oh...wait....that was a guy......

DeRoux's Broux said:

i thought it was "beans 'n franks, beans 'n franks"...oh...wait....that was a guy......

Click to expand...

And a different movie, n00b.

Dude said:

And a different movie, n00b.

Click to expand...

i know...just liked it better

Double fudge brownies! I guess they're cake.

Dude said:

And a different movie, n00b.

Click to expand...

Damn...you pwned him!!!

Walker said:

I diagree about cheesecake actually being a cake. I would argue that it is closer to a pie, despite what the name might advertise.

Click to expand...

AB* aggress with you on that, cheese cake is techically a custard pie.

I love pies (including cheese cake)

Kai


*Alton Brown

Well, if Alton feels that way, then it HAS to be true.

Any of you care to argue with Alton Brown? Huh?

I didn't THINK so....

-walker

pie, cake, cookies, brownies, whatever...

Gotta be Pie! Sweet AND savoury versions....so versatile. Whoever's heard of a savoury cake!!! Oh bugger.... Fishcakes.......

Pie...mmm pie....

Pecan rocks!

Apple and blackcurrant..

Mississippi Mud Pie...

...and I absolutely LOVE cheesecake!

Pie (and cheesecake). Except the wife likes cake. I think the ladies like cake more than pie personally. Yea, cake is in my house more than pie.

I used to make homemade pies; crust and all just to get some darn pies in the house. Too much work and not enough reward unlike brewing BEER!

I think of wild currant pie and I drool; then I think of red velvet cake and I drool; then I think of rhubarb pie and I drool; then I think of chocolate cake with chocolate icing and I drool; then I think of . . . . . . . . . . . . . I had to vote too busy drooling to choose.

Dude said:

Nahhh, I've had cheese pie, it sucks. And I'm from Wisconsin.

Click to expand...

Isn't that quiche? I love cheesecake and make a pretty good one. I'd argue that cheesecake is a custard, baked like a pie.

Still, I voted for cake. Portillo's chocolate cake is the best!

Nothing as good as a hot slice of apple pie right out of the oven with a dollup of vanilla ice cream drolling over the top! Yummmmm

DeejayDebi said:

Nothing as good as a hot slice of apple pie right out of the oven with a dollup of vanilla ice cream drolling over the top! Yummmmm

Click to expand...

Pie bitches!!!!

Dont forget a couple of thin slices of cheddar cheese on top before the ice cream.

That's right CF! And you have to let the cheese melt slightly before adding the icecream.

if there werent women on this site ocasionally I would have to mention that pie has to be greater then cake . . . you ever hear of hair cake?

Pies are the best. try a apple and rhubarb crumble. damn they are delicious

3 words, chocolate lava cake. The only good thing my wife ever brought home from a Pampered Chef party. Basically, it's chocolate cake made in a bunt pan and you add the chocolate icing in with the cake batter and bake it. The icing gets all warm and oozes down through all of the cake. Holy crap this stuff is good.....

Pie, man- gotta have rhubarb or apple. I don't have birthday cake, I have birthday Pie. Stick a candle in it and hand it over. And don't forget the ice cream. Oh , I love cheesecake, too. With crushed pineapples on it. MMMMMMMM.........

Apple pie, Key Lime pie, several "cakes" that could be classified as pie: PIE!

"Get your ***** ass back in the kitchen and make me some pie!"

- Eric Cartman

You guys need to check out "weebl and bob"
They live a very Pie-centric life

www.weebls-stuff.com