When unintentional contamination goes right

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

mccann51

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2011
Messages
227
Reaction score
3
Location
Somewhere
I brewed up a stout a few weeks back. Looking to get a dessert kind of stout, w oatmeal smoothness and chocolaty goodness. Here's the recipe to get an idea:

5 gal:
8 lbs American 2-row
0.75 lb chocolate malt
0.75 lb black malt
1 lb uncooked rolled oats
1 oz Magnum 60 min
1 oz Magnum 30 min
Safale-04 (rehydrated)
4 oz cocoa nibs in secondary
1 vanilla bean (Madagascar bourbon) in secondary
OG 1.050
FG 1.013

Well, somewhere along the line the batch got contaminated (perhaps the vanilla bean? I didn't sanitize that or the nibs). There was a really apparent Brett pellicle a couple days after I threw the vanilla bean in. I figured this beer was not going to be what I planned at all, but I've played w Brett and bacteria before, and I enjoy drinking funked and sour beers, so whatever, it'll be beer, I'll drink it. When I sampled it at bottling, I didn't notice anything funky, there was only a slight sourness, like a Brett sour, not a bacteria sour.

The other day, after just three or four days post-bottling, I cracked one open. Hot damn was it good! Tasted like chocolate covered cherries! Couldn't of asked for anything better, honestly. At first I couldn't really figure where the fruit flavor was coming from, but the next day I remembered that Brett can impart cherry pie flavors. I had totally forgotten, and was only thinking of the barnyard flavors when I saw it had gotten infected.

I plan to save a bottle to inoculate a similar batch down the road. Really pleased with how this turned out; very serendipitous.
 
1 Oct to 12 Nov. Not sure where you're getting a couple weeks from but it was about six weeks between brew day and bottling.
 
Sounds good to me. I have been drinking a lot of New Belgium Clutch, which is a blend of imperial stout and sour. It's damn good. The only bad thing is you may have trouble replicating this!
 
The only bad thing is you may have trouble replicating this!

Yeah, I'm hoping saving a bottle will allow me to have the yeast to at least attempt it. I don't keep track of temp, though, and I don't know exactly when the contamination occurred, so there's a lot of variables that will be unaccounted for. Either way, trying to brew it again will be a fun experiment!
 
You need to be careful with the bottles here. Even after 6 weeks, if you hadn't reached terminal gravity, you might have some exploding bottles. Brett will ferment sugars that Sacc can't/won't.
 
I'm in the "this might be a little soon to bottle" camp. I would have waited a couple of months to see if the gravity dropped anymore after initial sacc fermentation. If it was stable, I would bottle.
 
I'm in the "this might be a little soon to bottle" camp. I would have waited a couple of months to see if the gravity dropped anymore after initial sacc fermentation. If it was stable, I would bottle.

I'd be cautious with these bottles if you have any hanging around for a few months. As others mentioned, if you do have Brett in there it can keep chewing away at the residual sugars. Each gravity point represents .51 volumes co2 so that 1.013 FG could theoretically add another 6.5 volumes...about double the psi capacity of most 12 oz bottles.

having said all that, a funky cherry vanilla sour stout sounds amazingly delicious.
 
If its carbed and good you could always refrigerate them all. Or does brett and bugs not act like normal yeast when cooled?

Should slow them down if not stop them altogether. As soon as carb is where you want it, refrigerate and drink once a week noting the carb levels.

I did a Madrugada Obcura Clone that I aged on Michigan Cherries and it came out really well. Sour Stouts are the bomb. I'd like to get Some Clutch.
 
Back
Top