I have heard a hundred different opinions on what creates more or less carb...looking for some definitive information, also, so if you all discover anything, please post it. I'm in the process of growing a scoby from a bottle of GT's, so I haven't yet had the chance to do much. My husband is usually the brewer in the house, and he keeps asking me questions about kombucha brewing to which I have no real answers.
Well, I'm still very new at this, but here's what I've done/found.
My first bottle ever, I added some blueberries and left out for 2 days, then refrigerated. There was NO carbonation. I relate this to the short time I left it out. It was in a glass bottle, and I was afraid it would explode.
My first full gallon batch I bottled in PET plastic beer bottles I had on hand from an old beer kit. In these I added something different to each bottle: Ginger and lime juice, blueberries, cherries, and cherry berry juice (100% natural).
These I left out for four days, testing each day by squeezing the bottles. On the fourth day they all were pretty hard, with only a tiny bit of "give." I probably could have left them another day, maybe even longer, but I stuck them in the fridge at that point.
Yesterday I tried the bottle with cherry berry juice, and it was PERFECT. It had a very nice "smooth" effervescence to it, and the flavor of the juice was subtle and tasty.
The amount of days you should leave it out will vary, depending on what additions you use (if any), the amount of residual sugar in your Kombucha, and the temperature in the house.
Since there are so many variables, I'm always going to bottle at least one bottle in plastic, so I can test it by squeezing. This way I won't have to worry about exploding bottles.
One last note: each of the different flavorings definitely carbed at different rates. For instance, the bottle with cherries got hardest the quickest, and the one with ginger and lime took the longest. But they were fairly similar (enough so that I stuck them all in the fridge at the same time).
I will say though that the ones that would have had more added sugar seemed to carb more, which is what I would expect.
Cheers!