Quote:
Originally Posted by KingBrianI
Anyway, my recipe will have this grain bill with the addition of 2 oz of pale chocolate malt for some toastiness as per Jamil's suggestion. I'll also be aiming for 40 IBU with a 1 oz addition of NB at 15 and 1 oz at flameout.
|
Last night I poured a bottle of this and bottle of the real anchor steam side by side for a little taste comparison. Appearance-wise, my beer was definitely darker, probbaly by 2 SRM or so. Both were crystal clear but the anchor had an off-white head while my beer had more of a shining white head. My beer was much stonger in aroma, with lots of sweet malt and caramel, looots of caramel. Nice NB hoppiness in there too but the caramel definitely dominated. Anchor steam was more subdued, much less caramel, less hoppiness. The flavor of mine was definitely sweeter, with again, tons of caramel. Anchor was drier and more crisp, not displaying nearly the same caramel flavors. Toastiness was very similar between the two, and the overall impression of the flavor was similar, despite my beer having a much more dominant caramel flavor.
Overall, I'm very happy with the recipe. My wife preferred mine due to its maltiness. The caramel isn't something that is at all overwhelming of off-putting, but it definitely sticks out when compared to a real anchor.
When I make this beer again, I'm going to drop the crystal malt to about 0.5 lbs. That should reduce the color and caramel flavors to more closely approximate anchor, and will also give the beer a better impression of dryness. That would only be to bring the beer closer to anchor, not to necessarily improve upon it. As it is it is very good, and I wouldn't doubt if most people who tried it like it better than anchor (like my wife). It's definitely more flavorful and malty with bigger hop presence. The only advantage I see anchor having is a bit better drinkability due to it being a bit more dry and crisp. In cold weather, give me my attempt, in hot weather, give me the anchor.