I tried the regular craft glue stick but after a minute or so it would start peeling off of the bottle. I use HP Flyer & Brochure paper (matte) which is about twice as thick as your regular copy paper. I tried super glue too, and while it worked well for keeping the label on, it got on my finger and took days to come off haha!
Has anyone been successful using thicker paper as labels? If so, what kind of glue would you recommend?