As I am sure you know (mostly saying this to keep the ideas feasible here

), creating a membership not only has to provide some benefit that the member finds of value, but has to be fiscally reasonable on your end. Giving every member 10% off on all orders would be awesome on our part, but may not be the best for you. As a member, I would be willing to shell out $20 a year if I have a fair to good chance of recouping some of that value back, and not necessarily in the strict financial sense. Little things like free ice packs on yeast, priority filling on orders, and possibly even less restricted access to limited availability items (can order 6oz instead of 2oz of a limited variety hop, or can get some hops without grain purchase for example) are things I would see as a great value that even if abused by a few I don't see placing a huge burden on you.
I would say that monthly drawings from the member pool for little things like free shipping on an order, 10% off, $25 gift card, an extra year of membership, etc. would be a great idea as well. The chance to win a little swag is always welcome on our end
