Thx all. I'm going to cut down the caramel to 8oz and move the simcoe oz to FO. I'm becoming more of a hophead by the minute. I like IPA's bitter, but also with a big floral fruity bouquet. Some of my fav's are Ruination, Double Jack, and most recently Heady Topper has ruined a lot of other beers for me...its incredible. My last IIPA didn't have a big aroma which dissappointed me.