Home Brew Forums

Home Brew Forums (http://www.homebrewtalk.com/forum.php)
-   Beginners Beer Brewing Forum (http://www.homebrewtalk.com/f39/)
-   -   mr.beer+ 1lb table sugar! (http://www.homebrewtalk.com/f39/mr-beer-1lb-table-sugar-408211/)

redstar89 04-30-2013 02:28 AM

mr.beer+ 1lb table sugar!
 
Okay i added about 1 lb of white granulated table sugar to a mr.beer all malt Oktoberfest kit! and brought the water up to a little over 2 gallons its going wicked in teh fermentation what can i expect from this bath? How much alco the flavor and also how do i get it to carb up good the mr. beer 1 liter requirements hardly carb it at all!

homebrewdad 04-30-2013 02:47 AM

It'll be drier and boozier than the recipe called for. Carbonation won't change - follow your directions to carb per normal.

BigFloyd 04-30-2013 04:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by redstar89 (Post 5154043)
Okay i added about 1 lb of white granulated table sugar to a mr.beer all malt Oktoberfest kit! and brought the water up to a little over 2 gallons its going wicked in teh fermentation what can i expect from this bath? How much alco the flavor and also how do i get it to carb up good the mr. beer 1 liter requirements hardly carb it at all!

What is it that you were trying to accomplish by adding the 1 lb of table sugar?

chumpsteak 04-30-2013 04:24 AM

Were you trying to make ethanol to run your car on? You might as well because you most likely ruined your beer.

redstar89 04-30-2013 06:16 AM

now why would that of ruined my beer?

DrunkleJon 04-30-2013 11:11 AM

Adding extra sugar will dry out your beer. If you put more sugars in which raises the ABV, you could go over the alcohol tolerance of the yeast and end up with residual sugars. Additionally if you add too much white sugar you can get strange ciderish flavors. Were you trying to make Malt liquor or something? I cannot personally see the rationale for adding a LB of white sugar to a 2 gal Mr. Beer but that is just me.

VT-NAV 04-30-2013 03:29 PM

We need to cut the guy a little slack. Perhaps he's posting on the beginner forum because he just began? Of course people who've been brewing a long time know that adding a pound of table sugar to a 2-gallon batch is a bad idea, but he clearly does not -- because he's just new to the hobby. The purpose of this subforum is to welcome new people into the hobby with constructive feedback, not make them feel dumb.

In his defense, I'll say that the Mr. Beer directions (at least the version I read several years ago) explicitly state that you can add sugar to adjust ABV, but are very vague as to how much can be added. They are also vague on the potential negative impact of adding too much.

To the OP: if you were brewing a larger, 5-gallon batch, then adding a pound of table sugar would have a much less noticeable effect. The proportion of sugar to extract in your 2-gallon Mr. Beer batch is quite high, and will most likely result in some off-flavors -- chiefly, a strong scent and taste of what can only be likened to cider.

My first batch ever was a Mr. Beer kit I got for Christmas in 2001. I got around to brewing it several years later. Stale extract + ancient yeast + corn sugar that had melted and then hardened into a brick = beer that tastes like a 50/50 mix of Mich Ultra and apple cider vinegar. We still keep a bottle in the medicine cabinet in case we need to induce vomiting.

If the beer does turn out terrible, I strongly urge you to consider trying again with a proper setup. If you have a homebrew shop nearby, stop in some time and look at what a basic brewing setup. After my abyssmal brewing failure, I bought a copy of The Complete Joy of Homebrewing by Charlie Papazian on Amazon. I read up on the hobby, figured out what I did wrong, and got back into it with the proper tools and ingredients.

DrunkleJon 04-30-2013 04:10 PM

True. My apologies if I sounded accusing or mocking. It is true that we all start out at the beginning and should not judge. Probably should have worded it slightly different, though usually it is better to ask what effect it would have before rather than after

And Mr. Beer can make good beer. Heck many people here use their Little Brown Kegs (LBK's) to brew up small batch or test batches using regular ingredients and not just the canned worts. OP. Ask and we will answer what we can. Its just oftentimes when we start hearing about pounds of table sugar being added on a first brew we start hearing about bread yeast and hootchmaking and kind of get our backs up. Homebrew is what we do. Prison Wine... yecch.

agcorry00 04-30-2013 05:43 PM

The first time I ever brewed was with a friend and his Mr. Beer kit. Even after dropping a fork in the cooled wort and retrieving it with a bare hand it turned out ok. We called it Stinkfist Ale.

dstranger99 04-30-2013 06:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by redstar89 (Post 5154476)
now why would that of ruined my beer?

1 pound of sugar into a 5 gallon batch could be a disaster, your batch is just a little over 2.........


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:37 AM.

Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.