35-40+ IBU's does not necessarily mean hoppy. It really depends how it's done i.e. late aroma additions versus early bittering ones...
I'm just saying.
Try this one from NB since you will be using their LME anyway.
http://www.northernbrewer.com/documentation/beerkits/AmericanRye.pdf
Doesn't seem to list the IBU's but they can't be much with those hops listed in those amounts.
__________________
In Queue: Raspberry Melomel, Black IPA, Rye IPA, Colonial Porter, Wee Heavy, BoPils, Dubbel, Hefe, GF IPA
Fermenting/Lagering: Rye Barleywine, Best Bitter, Brett Saison, Tripel, Single IPA, PtY Clone, BGSA, Berliner, Quad, Apricot pLambic, Flanders Red
Kegged: English IPA, American IPA, Marzen, Black IPA, Milk Stout, Schwarzbier, Bourbon Barrel Milk Stout
2012 Medal Count: 11
|