Home Brew Forums

Home Brew Forums (http://www.homebrewtalk.com/forum.php)
-   All Grain & Partial Mash Brewing (http://www.homebrewtalk.com/f36/)
-   -   Water Profiles (http://www.homebrewtalk.com/f36/water-profiles-58037/)

Dr_Deathweed 03-07-2008 10:48 PM

Water Profiles
 
I know our water sucks:
Ca = 3ppm
Mg = 0.7ppm
Na = 200ppm
SO4 = 9ppm
Cl = 54ppm
Bicarb = 459ppm

I have a big brew day coming up on the 16th and i am going to be doing 3 widely different styles; a Koelsch, a brown ale, and a stout. My hope is that by using a mixture of distilled water, local water, and some simple salts (Epsom, gypsum, CaCl) to come up with some halfway decent water profiles. I know I could build my own profile from scratch, but i am trying to keep it simply complex as possible:D

I have been trying to mess with water profiles using beer smith and brewater 3.0, but beer smith has no self calculation feature, and brewater won't work with our water profile. (Try it, enter my water profile, dilute it 100% with distilled, and it still will not self calculate the ion additions. Either that or I am stupid) Here is my idea so far:

Koelsch: Target Cologne Germany (edit: had trouple finding a profile for this area, if anyone has a reliable source, please let me know)
5 gal distilled, 2.25gal local water, 4g gypsum, 1g epsom salt, 5g CaCl
resulting profile:
Ca = 84.8ppm
Mg = 3.8ppm
Na = 62.1ppm
SO4 = 98.7.3ppm
Cl = 104.3ppm
Bicarb =142.4ppm


Brown Ale: Target London.
5gal distilled, 2.75 gal local water, 2g gypsum, 4g epsom salt, 2.5g CaCl. resulting profile:
Ca = 40.3ppm
Mg = 13.7ppm
Na = 71ppm
SO4 = 94.5ppm
Cl = 60ppm
Bicarb =162ppm

Stout: Target Dublin
5gal distilled, 1.5gal local water, 2g gypsum, 1g epsom, 2gCaCl, 4g chalk
resulting profile:
Ca = 107ppm
Mg = 4ppm
Na = 46.2ppm
SO4 = 63.5ppm
Cl = 51.5ppm
Bicarb =203ppm


Do these values look right/feasable? Is there a better and easier way to get the same results? I usually use 5.2 in my mash, but as a phosphate buffer, will it not precipitate out any Ca I put into my water? Thanks for the help.

Got Trub? 03-10-2008 03:18 AM

The stout and brown ale won't need 5.2, the dark grains will pull your pH into the appropriate range for mashing.

GT

Aclay 03-10-2008 10:27 AM

according to my source (CJHB Papazian pg. 263) your Dublin water profile is way off. Here's what Papazian gives.

Ca 115-120
SO4 54
Mg 4
Na 12
Cl 19

as far as the other two go I've no clue.

Alemental 03-10-2008 12:11 PM

Cologne (Koln) water profile here:

http://www.homebrewtalk.com/wiki/index.php/K%C3%B6ln

MashStirBrew 03-10-2008 06:27 PM

I have been having this problem too. Noonan in New Lager Beers has this for London water:

CA 90
Mg 5
Na 15
SO4 40
Cl 20
HCO3 125

Designing Great Beers has this for London:

Ca 50
Mg 20
Na 100
SO4 80
Cl 60
HCO3 160

And BeerSmith has completely different numbers as well! This has been my experience with basically All water profiles. I wish I could help rather than confuse you more, but hopefully the experts can chime in and clear this up for us...

Dr_Deathweed 03-11-2008 03:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aclay
according to my source (CJHB Papazian pg. 263) your Dublin water profile is way off.


Right, I know it is not spot on, but it was as close as I could get given the dilution and salts I detailed above the profile. Given RO, my water profile, and some SIMPLE salt mesurements (I can only wiegh in gram increments right now) If any one wants to play around and get something closer, be my guest. Also let me know if my ballpark figgures are completely out of whack.

uhlee1, yeah, I noticed this as well. 10 different profiles from 10 different sources. Kinda like a poll on the best method of sparging:D My numbers above are pretty much ballpark of what I could hit with what I have. I was wondering if there are people out there (and I am sure there is) that play with water extensivly and know a better way to go at this, or can even narrow it down to 2 or 3 profiles that get most any beer that you would like to brew. Because to me, the Koln and London profile don't look that much different....

jbford 03-11-2008 02:45 PM

water profile
 
add some CaSO4 if you want higher Ca and to also handle the bicarb. Add lactic if you want to leave Ca level where it is

dilute if you want lower Na

high bicarb can be handled by lowering the pH alone without dilution.



JBFord
(geezer, chemist)

Homebrewjosh 03-12-2008 02:58 AM

Check out Brewwater 3.0 when you get a chance. It's free and it helps with calculations


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:24 PM.

Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.