As a follow-up to this post, since the original information is pretty useful, I recently tried a proper paint stripper with the following beer bottles:
- Sam Adams Barrel Room varieties
- Rogue (fully-painted bottles, as in the pumpkin seasonal variety)
- Rogue (standard painted bottles, with a person's face or other logo, with much of the text reversed out)
Here are my results:
- At ~15 minutes (the time indicated on the paint stripper product), the paint of the fully-painted bottle had bubbled up quite promisingly:
- The Sam Adams bottles were unchanged in appearance:
- The standard Rogue bottle appeared to show some change, but only a little:
In the end, even with washing and scrubbing under the hose, the fully-painted bottles were the only ones that showed any noticeable change. And, while most of the paint did finally come off, there was still a sticky film coating the bottles.
Additionally, since I couldn't be sure I'd washed off all of the paint stripper, I was uneasy about using them for bottling purposes.
None of the other designs/patterns I tested against showed any meaningful change at all. Interestingly, the Rogue bottles' success changed with the color of the paint. The Rogue Double (bright red with lots of logo stuff on the 'face') didn't want to clean up at all, while the orange pumpkin brew bottle cleaned up the best of the lot.
I'd still like to be able to use the Sam Adams Barrel Room bottles (they sure are nice!), but I'm thinking this chemical solution might not be the right approach.
Has anyone managed to successfully erase some/all of the marketing on that variety?