TipsyDragon

Recipes 

i know this is normal so I'm not even remotely worried. i am making a blueberry melomel and this past Saturday i racked my 5 gallons of mead onto 6lb. of blueberry puree with a teaspoon of pectic enzyme. there was evidence of renewed fermentation within minutes of racking and placing of airlock. when i was racking i simultaneously poured dry ice fog into the secondary effectively filling it with CO2. this coupled with the CO2 put out by the now fermenting yeast has filled my headspace with plenty of CO2 gas. now, this morning i checked on things and there was a fairly thick layer of blueberries floating at the top of the carboy. i know this is normal because the yeast are eating the sugar and producing CO2 and making the blueberries float.

my question is, should i shake the carboy and make the mat of blueberries sink back down to the bottom or just let it be? i can't see why shaking would be a bad thing. what do you guys think?

Yooper

Recipes 

I wouldn't shake it, unless the floating "cap" of berries is drying out on top.

You don't want the fruit to dry out.

__________________
Broken Leg Brewery
Giving beer a leg to stand on since 2006

fatbloke

Recipes 

Ah! whereas I'd be gently swirling it as you want to keep the fruit in contact with the yeast cells as much as possible. I find that way, the pulp/cap eventually sinks with the rest of the lees......

S'up to you.....

__________________
"What the large print giveth, the small print taketh away". Tom Waits.

Oh, and here's some blog stuff!

gratus fermentatio

Recipes 

+ 1 on the gentle swirl, too rough & it could cause it to foam up considerably.

malkore

Recipes 

or use a spoon to punch the fruit back down in.
otherwise be REAL gentle on swirling the carboy

__________________
Malkore
Primary: English Mild
On tap: Pale Ale, Lancelot's Wheat, English Brown Ale, Steam Beer, HoovNuts IPA
Bottled: MOAM, Braggot, Raspberry Melomel, Merlot, Apfelwein, Pyment, Sweet mead, Cabernet
Gal in 2009: 27, Gal in 2010: 34, Gal in 2011: 13, Gal in 2012: 10

TipsyDragon

Recipes 

problem with that is that it runs the risk of contamination from opening the carboy then jabbing it with a spoon. besides i don't have a spoon small enough to fit through the neck of the carboy or with a long enough handle to reach the fruit.

as far as being gentle when swirling i don't see why. the head space is totally full of CO2 so its not like i'm going to oxidize it.

Androshen

Recipes 

If you are using a Better Bottle carboy, I saw a video online about the best way to swirl one ....
You place a ball in the recess under the carboy and then simply "roll" the carboy in a rotating fashion on the ball.
It was all pretty slick .......





"Swirling the contents of a Better-Bottle carboy vigorously requires almost no effort, if a tennis ball is placed in the punt space under the carboy. Do not tilt the carboy by so much that the edge of the carboy's base touches the surface (see Important Note). And perform the swirling on a smooth or soft surface for good measure. Leave extra head space during initial mixing and aeration to maximize agitation. Tune your swirling motion for the desired effect; very hard swirling may result in less efficient mixing than more gentle swirling.

Important Note: Never rock or swirl Better-Bottle carboys without using a tennis ball. Doing so will cause the edges of the bottom of the carboy to flex under great stress repeatedly and eventually cause cracks, like bending a paper clip back and forth. "

__________________
Whatever doesn't kill me ...... had better run alot faster than I can ....

TipsyDragon

Recipes 

thanks for the info but i don't use BBs, don't like the idea of an acidic mead sitting in plastic for several months. i'm using a 6.5 gallon glass carboy.

fatbloke

Recipes 

Well the handle of a plastic stirring paddle would do the job just as easily. If you've sanitised it, it's possible, though unlikely, that you'll introduce spoilage organisms (see below)
Ok, so on the face of it, that'd make sense, but it's about meads (and other alcoholic brews for that matter) and the way that CO2 which is currently in solution in the ferment, is released.

Imagine you've shaken the hell out of a bottle of coke or something carbonated like that, but then put it back in the fridge for a couple of hours.

When you come to open it, it starts to fizz/foam, but there's a slight delay before it goes batsh1t and erupts out of the top.

It can be (not necessarily) similar with a ferment, you can give it a gentle swirl and the movement is enough to re-incorporate the fruit into the liquid part, without causing mead fountains. While you could easily be just a little bit less gentle and it's enough to cause the CO2 to come out of solution and foam like hell, coming out the top or through the airlock etc.

You've already shown that you're thinking on the right lines by questioning the use of a spoon/paddle/whatever and the potential for introducing spoilage organisms, which it a good way to be thinking (though you'd still be in the same position when racking/syphoning/bottling etc.... see where I'm going ???), so why not just be gentle with the ferment and swirl it enough just to mix the fruit back in. The idea of the tennis ball trick from BB is just as valid with glass, not that you're likely to get stress cracks but the weight on the tennis ball will allow enough clearance for you to be able to swirl the carboy in a circular motion enough to get the fruit pulp moving back into the liquid, as it should disturb enough of the CO2 in the fermenting part of the fruit to allow it to sink again - the CO2 coming out, as usual through the airlock.

Don't forget, CO2 is (apparently) a "heavier than air" gas, so unless you're racking from one container to another (enclosed containers that is), either the active fermenting part or the natural de-gas of a finished ferment, is going to continue to produce CO2 just on top of the liquid providing a CO2 rich blanket of gas. It's the same reason why you'd normally reduce the airspaces in secondary or finished ferments. We don't have a chemical laboratory in our back pocket, so there's practically no way of measuring the CO2 content of the gas layer. It's just to be on the safe side.

Besides, meads and honey based ferments seem to be more resistant to oxidation than "normal" wines..... I think it's something to do with the properties of the honey........

good luck with the brew....

regards

fatbloke

__________________
"What the large print giveth, the small print taketh away". Tom Waits.

Oh, and here's some blog stuff!

TipsyDragon

Recipes 

while i do appreciate your advice there are a few flaws in your logic.

the reason the soda bottle gushes after shaking is because there is more than 1 atmosphere of CO2 dissolved in solution and the shaking releases it. during fermentation any CO2 above 1 atmosphere is released into the headspace of the carboy and pushes out the airlock equalizing the pressure.

i know the head space is completely full of CO2 because when i was racking i filled the headspace with dry ice fog which is almost totally CO2 then applied an airlock. so the CO2 can get out but no outside air can get back in. Also when i added the fruit the yeast that was in suspension in the mead began eating the sugars from the blueberries and began fermentation again, producing more CO2. the airlock is bubbling ever so often releasing pressure.

the rather inventive and cool BB/tennis ball idea works because of the indentation in the bottom of the BB. it prevents the ball from rolling/sliding out from under the bottle while swirling. a glass carboy has a flat or almost flat bottom. i would be to afraid the ball would just slide or roll out from under the bottle.