Thank you all. It took about a week or so to do: a couple hours a night whittling and then 24 hours between varnish coats.
This was kind of a one-off since I just used some scrap wood and I scavenged the hardware off another tap handle to make it. However, since I am planning on adding a second tap to the kegerator soon anyway, I'll let you know if I make any more. It was a fun project, afterall.