I might go the Nottingham route 1st since I can't find anyone who's been able to carb Montrachet with corn sugar.
I used the Montrachet and got good carbonation with corn sugar. Took about 3 weeks in the bottle. Unfortunately I did't document how much corn sugar (I think it was 1/2 cup) since I plan on kegging my next batch. Hopefully I will have all the equipment by then.
__________________ "When the going get weird, the weird turn pro." Raoul Duke
This is a great thread, though a bit daunting in length - 53 pages of reading left me thirsty, thank you Toot for the summary. Now I gotta hurry up so I can wait 4-6 weeks to try something tastey. I am a big fan of ciders, my favorite is Strongbow, but with regards to Scrumpy Jack - ick, I'd rather drink Hornsby! Blackthorn is nice. I've onced tried some really strong local "Scrumpy" cider while traveling in Wales - I was already well into my cups that night though. It's about time I try my hand at "brewing" some.
Here's what I am thinking about:
4 gallons Apple juice
1 # brown sugar
SafAle US 56 (it's on hand)
2 tsp. yeast nutrients
__________________
Slán,
~A. MadPoet
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ On Tap: Summer Blonde Ale Primary: Irish Red Ale Planned: MadPoet's Pagan Ale
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
SafAle US 56 (it's on hand)
2 tsp. yeast nutrients
I highly suggest starting with the original recipe. It' shard to try to improve on something if you don't know what it tastes like to begin with. ...and honestly, the original is darn good.
__________________ On Tap:Whatever I just brewed (got sick of updating it)
I went as the recipe goes, using the Montrachet yeast, however I included yeast nutrient. I checked out a couple written sources, and a nutrient is recommended with ciders.
Now to wait it out...
__________________
Success is getting what you want. Happiness is wanting what you get. - Dale Carnegie
Well, I've been keeping my eye on this thread and I finally made a cider on Friday using Tree Top from Costco and Red Star Primere Cuvee Yeast. My LHBS was out of Montrachet. Today, (Sunday), I got about three hours worth of nasty rotten egg smell but that was it. Cleared up super fast. Since I'm 3 or 4 days into this, does anybody have any idea if it is too late to add yeast nutrient? Should I even bother?
Thanks Edwort for posting this recipe. Can't wait to try it.
I had to use Primere Cuvee yeast on my first batch of Apfelwein as well because my LHBS didn't stock Montrachet. The apfelwein was a little rough at first but after a month in the bottle it is great. I liked this Apfelwein so much I got a second batch going already.
__________________ Primary #1: Dunkelweizen Primary #2: Empty Secondary #1: Blackberry Wine Secondary #2: Apple Wine Secondary #3: Saison Bottled: Raspberry Barkshack Ginger Mead, Belgian Wit, Rye IPA, Coffee Stout, Amber Ale In The Works: Porter, Wee Heavy
I'm not that familiar with yeast nutrients but by following Ed's recipe exactly I fermented down to 0.995 so I don't think it's necessary (ie wasting $)...