blacklick wine and spirits on broad street is pretty awesome. they have homebrew supplies as well as a kick ass selection of craft beer. they also do tastings every thursday/friday of a different brewery for $6.
My goto store is Andersons - I'm a regular and can get items not advertised or have yet to be shelved. Kenny Rd. Market has a fine selection as well. Gentiles is my LHBS because it is pretty much on my way home from the office. Barley hopsters is pretty cool as well. Found a Stone 10-10-10 there plus you have to love a place you can grab something out of the cooler and crack it open on the spot lol.