My father-in-law isn't a very good critic, he tends to "like" everything I brew. My SWMBO thinks that all beer tastes the same (terrible). So I try to critique myself, but I need more experience. I had one terrible batch which I eventually poured, but all of the others were quite nice (in my mind). Since I don't intend to join any contests, I am trying to hone in on that beer that I like, and make it as cheaply as I can.
Primary: One Buck Bombers II
Bottle Conditioning: One Buck Bombers I
Now Serving: Lil' Sumpin' Sumpin'
Drunk: Celebration Ale, Fat Tire, Two Hearted Ale, Speedway Stout, SNPA, SNPA w/Simcoe, Moose Drool, Dale's Pale Ale
On Deck: One Buck Bombers III