Hummm...
I'm planning those six brews in the next two months. I got an interest in Mangrove Jack's -- the flavour profiles are varied and interesting, attenuation isn't over the top (something I look for, considering the list below), I'm bored of S-04 which I find VERY interesting in Stouts and Porters but whose lactic and mineral tang (my English Brown Ale is absolutely great if you feel like licking a rock) makes it just not the most interesting choice for what I wanna brew, and the temperature to which I can keep my beers without trouble (let's say 63-to-66) make US-05 frankly inappropriate (peachy Wee Heavy?... nope). Notty would probably ferment dirty underwears and Windsor just feels.... boring.
________________________________________
Here are my project brews :
- Special Bitter, +- 1.045 OG
- Porter with a twist (it will be smoky, not from the malts), +- 1.055 OG
- Light Scotch Ale/Wee Heavy, if that makes any sense, 1.075 OG
- Irish Red (or my interpretation of it : a Red Ale with 2-Row and Roasted Barley only as malts), 1.050 OG
- Galaxy-driven Hefe Weizen on the high-end of SRM/OG/IBU (basically, my take on the sublime Mein Nelson Sauvin), +- 1.055 OG
- Dark Weizenbock, 1.075 OG
I brew 1 gallon batches, which means I make two beers with one pack (and usually have a tiny amount of leftovers, which might be useful).
____________________________________
Well, first of all, and before choosing the right yeast... The whole 50 billion cells kinda scare the crap out of me. That basically means one pack for my two big beers (I also go for 0.75 in Brewers Friend). That also means that I could be manageable to pitch +- 40% of the pack in the Bitter and the reminder in the Porter. Not ideal, but certainly manageable. Still, that's a problem.
____________________________________
Second, I must choose the yeast and figure out ideal pairings. Let's assume the Yeast Count is similar to Fermentis/Danstar for the purposes of this exercise.
The choice is easy with the Weizens. M20.
The Bitter calls for Burton Union.
The Porter would call for either Burton Union or British Ale.
I mean, it would certainly call for British Ale more than Burton Union (pear in kiwis in a Porter?), but I gather that, if fermented in my usual range, those esters will fade away, especially in a beer containing 20% of Brown Malt/Chocolate Malt. It's something the spec sheet alludes to.
The problem is with the Wee Heavy/SSA and the Irish Red.
Going purely by profiles, Newcastle Dark Ale just feels absolutely perfect with those dark fruits esters. You don't want esters in a SSA, but if you HAVE to get them, go for dark fruits. And I could certainly live with a 65% attenuation (technically, lower-end of specs). It will be sweet and have plenty of body, which is the whole point. And an Irish Red finishing in the 1.016 range at 5% isn't bad either if the profile of the yeast fits the description.
But then, you have this message on the spec sheets :
Higher alcohol beers will tend to be slightly too sweet and heavy due to the moderate attenuative capabilities of the strain although a lower mash temperature may help the fermentability and lower the final gravity.
Usually, spec sheets tend to boost their products, as opposed to saying something like "don't do that". The thing is, the specs sheet also mentions this :
Traditional Scotch Ale : British Ale Yeast
Scottish Style Heavy Ale : Newcastle Dark Ale Yeast
I don't know what that means, but I suspect my Strong Scotch Ale fits in the first category rather than in the second.
The other problem I see is the many comments on how Newcastle Dark Ale attenuates terribly. On a 1.075 beer, including 14% of Caramunich, Honey Malt (which is a decent fermentable from what I gather... but sweet) and Chocolate Malt, this seems to be a recipe for disaster.
So 2nd option for yeast pairing would be
British Ale : Strong Scotch Ale (not even strong actually...) and Porter.
Burton Union : Irish and Bitter
But then again, this mention, for strong beers :
Ester formation will be slightly elevated in higher alcohol beers, but the character of esters will be pleasant with ripe apple and pear dominating, along with faint banana. Beer will be dry, but a perception of malt sweetness will survive in the aftertaste along with malt character and
complexity. Alcohol should be warming, not hot
I don't know which is worse : 55% attenuation or a Strong Scotch Ale-meets-Weizen brew. Either way, from what I gathered, the British Ale yeast can ferment really clean, which works well in a SSA. But then again -- thin mouthfeel?
______________________________________
The 3rd option is yeast blending, especially for the SSA, which I'm strongly considering at this point (really, just .5 grams of US-5 or S-4 should do it).
______________________________________
I swear I'll give some feedback if ever I chose the Mangrove Jack route. Profiles are very interesting, but some experiences are a bit wacky.
I'm planning those six brews in the next two months. I got an interest in Mangrove Jack's -- the flavour profiles are varied and interesting, attenuation isn't over the top (something I look for, considering the list below), I'm bored of S-04 which I find VERY interesting in Stouts and Porters but whose lactic and mineral tang (my English Brown Ale is absolutely great if you feel like licking a rock) makes it just not the most interesting choice for what I wanna brew, and the temperature to which I can keep my beers without trouble (let's say 63-to-66) make US-05 frankly inappropriate (peachy Wee Heavy?... nope). Notty would probably ferment dirty underwears and Windsor just feels.... boring.
________________________________________
Here are my project brews :
- Special Bitter, +- 1.045 OG
- Porter with a twist (it will be smoky, not from the malts), +- 1.055 OG
- Light Scotch Ale/Wee Heavy, if that makes any sense, 1.075 OG
- Irish Red (or my interpretation of it : a Red Ale with 2-Row and Roasted Barley only as malts), 1.050 OG
- Galaxy-driven Hefe Weizen on the high-end of SRM/OG/IBU (basically, my take on the sublime Mein Nelson Sauvin), +- 1.055 OG
- Dark Weizenbock, 1.075 OG
I brew 1 gallon batches, which means I make two beers with one pack (and usually have a tiny amount of leftovers, which might be useful).
____________________________________
Well, first of all, and before choosing the right yeast... The whole 50 billion cells kinda scare the crap out of me. That basically means one pack for my two big beers (I also go for 0.75 in Brewers Friend). That also means that I could be manageable to pitch +- 40% of the pack in the Bitter and the reminder in the Porter. Not ideal, but certainly manageable. Still, that's a problem.
____________________________________
Second, I must choose the yeast and figure out ideal pairings. Let's assume the Yeast Count is similar to Fermentis/Danstar for the purposes of this exercise.
The choice is easy with the Weizens. M20.
The Bitter calls for Burton Union.
The Porter would call for either Burton Union or British Ale.
I mean, it would certainly call for British Ale more than Burton Union (pear in kiwis in a Porter?), but I gather that, if fermented in my usual range, those esters will fade away, especially in a beer containing 20% of Brown Malt/Chocolate Malt. It's something the spec sheet alludes to.
The problem is with the Wee Heavy/SSA and the Irish Red.
Going purely by profiles, Newcastle Dark Ale just feels absolutely perfect with those dark fruits esters. You don't want esters in a SSA, but if you HAVE to get them, go for dark fruits. And I could certainly live with a 65% attenuation (technically, lower-end of specs). It will be sweet and have plenty of body, which is the whole point. And an Irish Red finishing in the 1.016 range at 5% isn't bad either if the profile of the yeast fits the description.
But then, you have this message on the spec sheets :
Higher alcohol beers will tend to be slightly too sweet and heavy due to the moderate attenuative capabilities of the strain although a lower mash temperature may help the fermentability and lower the final gravity.
Usually, spec sheets tend to boost their products, as opposed to saying something like "don't do that". The thing is, the specs sheet also mentions this :
Traditional Scotch Ale : British Ale Yeast
Scottish Style Heavy Ale : Newcastle Dark Ale Yeast
I don't know what that means, but I suspect my Strong Scotch Ale fits in the first category rather than in the second.
The other problem I see is the many comments on how Newcastle Dark Ale attenuates terribly. On a 1.075 beer, including 14% of Caramunich, Honey Malt (which is a decent fermentable from what I gather... but sweet) and Chocolate Malt, this seems to be a recipe for disaster.
So 2nd option for yeast pairing would be
British Ale : Strong Scotch Ale (not even strong actually...) and Porter.
Burton Union : Irish and Bitter
But then again, this mention, for strong beers :
Ester formation will be slightly elevated in higher alcohol beers, but the character of esters will be pleasant with ripe apple and pear dominating, along with faint banana. Beer will be dry, but a perception of malt sweetness will survive in the aftertaste along with malt character and
complexity. Alcohol should be warming, not hot
I don't know which is worse : 55% attenuation or a Strong Scotch Ale-meets-Weizen brew. Either way, from what I gathered, the British Ale yeast can ferment really clean, which works well in a SSA. But then again -- thin mouthfeel?
______________________________________
The 3rd option is yeast blending, especially for the SSA, which I'm strongly considering at this point (really, just .5 grams of US-5 or S-4 should do it).
______________________________________
I swear I'll give some feedback if ever I chose the Mangrove Jack route. Profiles are very interesting, but some experiences are a bit wacky.