i got mine yesterday and they were perfect. if you got rejects, i'd contact them and see if you can get replacements.
for anyone wondering, it does NOT look like you are texting a third-party. the link i posted takes you DIRECTLY to the bostonbrewing.com webpage. i confirmed this when i did a google search for this offer and found the same page.
There is no "good beer" and "bad beer." Only what you like. Save the snobbery for the wine and cheese crowd.