Dirty Bilge Brewing
Swashbuckler Brewing Co already exists in Manheim, PA.
I'd second the Shipwrecked idea...sounds good and a catchy slogan to go with it.
Be a winner...score a "Hat Trick"
Keel Haul Brewhaus
Considering where you are located, Night Raider Brewing might be a good one (in honor of Washington's Delaware crossing).
Three Sheets Brewing. Good luck getting it by Pleepleus.
Dark Shoals Brewing.
Triton Brewing Company.
Sunken Grotto Brewing -- Come and drink like a fish.
Chanel marker[insert lucky # here]
Yada, yada , yada...
The Filthy Whore