A couple comments:
1) Was this AG, PM or extract? If it was anything other than AG it is more likely your SG reading was erroneous for some reason than as high as you saw. I've had issues with wacky SG readings, I now ensure the wort of well stirred before pulling a sample. I know with a fermented batch it is harder to do this, but worth a shot.
2) What is the recipe? Did you validate the expected gravity readings with another beer calculator? I've had a prepackaged recipe that came in way different than the box, the HBS made a typo.
3) What is the timeline? A beer typically likes time on the yeast cake, the larger the beer the more it can help, prior to racking/bottling/messing around with. I know a rule of thumb often pitched was the 1-2-3 (1 week primary, 2 week secondary, 3 week bottle carb (if needed)), but i've moved to a 3-4 week primary, 1 week secondary, and 2 week bottle carb and have been happy with the results.
That is my input, if I'm wrong someone should be awake soon to correct.
