This is my first non "kit" brew. I tweaked another recipe I found somewhere. I'll be happy to read any comments or suggestions.
I'll touch base with results when complete.
Type: Extract
Batch Size: 5 gal
Boil: 3 gal
Total Grain/Extract: 10.25lbs
Dextrose Priming Sugar
Yeast: Liquid California Ale WLP001
1 lb Crystal Malt 45
.25 German Munich
9 lb LME
60: 1.5 oz Simcoe
15: 1 oz Simcoe
FO: 1 oz Simcoe
Dry Hop: 1 oz Simcoe
Irish Moss
Going for about 75 IBU.
Question: I'll have an extra .5 oz of Simcoe laying around. Who is in favor of dumping it in @ 30 min? Who is in favor of keeping it for another batch?
You could keep the 1oz of dryhop out of the batch and then make a simcoe pale ale with the remaining 1.5 oz. I'd probably spread the additions out evenly (.5 oz each) at 20, 15, 10, 5, 0.
My .02 is to break up that 15 min. addition in half and add the other half at 10 minutes. I would also add that extra .5 oz at 5 min as well. If that makes your IBUs too high, I would lower your 60 min addition to 1oz and maybe add the difference at the Dryhop. I have an IPA that has medaled twice using Simcoe at 15, 10, & 5 minutes and it has a very smooth hop flavor.
Simcoe is a terrific flavor and aroma hop and I think your current recipe will turn out great. Good Luck!
In terms of taste or smell, you ought to probably taste/smell an IPA that features only one type of hop so you can "get to know it" without other hop varieties interfering.
I'd move some of the 60' addition to 30' to get more hop flavor. Simcoe to me tastes like a citrus fruit salad served on a freshly cut pine board.
You don't need a flameout and a dry hop addition IMO, depends on what you want. The aroma will be grassier from dry hop, whereas the flameout will be more rounded.