Originally Posted by Yuri_Rage
Geez, I feel bad that I kinda hijacked your thread with the metallurgy discussion. To get back to the point, the Star San bath should do the trick whether it's stainless or aluminum. I'm guessing that it's an aluminum pot, as stainless shouldn't leave a metallic flavor like that, even after being scrubbed bare.
No worries on where the thread went, I was getting a kick out of it and even chuckled as I told the wife about it.
So based on everyone's feedback - this thing is aluminum. I'm going to go for the Star San bath instead of putting it in the oven for 6 hours since I don't really want to run my electric oven for 6 hours. Between the electric $$$ and having to keep my 20 month old away from the oven/kitchen for that long the chemical solution is definitly the easiest to try.
I'm kicking around the idea of an altbier for the next batch, or a california common, and hopefully whatever I go with won't have that flavor lingering around.