Don’t fear the Starsan foam, a math explanation

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

DirtyPolock

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2010
Messages
293
Reaction score
6
Location
Durham, NC
So I don’t know if something like this exists somewhere else on the forum so my apologies if this is a duplicate. I want to try to explain why to not fear the foam via math.

Starsan has two active ingredients: Dodecylbenzenesulfonic acid (DDBSA) and Phosphoric acid (PA). Their concentration in straight starsan is 15% and 50% respectively. This means that for every mL of starsan there is 150 mg of DDBSA and 500 mg of PA.

If you mix up a 5 gallon batch of Starsan in your ale pail fermenter and use the recommended 30 mL of starsan then you have a total of 4.5 grams of DDBSA and 15 grams of PA per 5 gallons (18,927 mL) of water. This results in a concentration of 0.238 mg/mL of DDBSA and 0.793 mg/mL of PA in this mix.

At this point you will empty your ale pail before you add in your wort and yeast to make beer. After dumping your starsan batch you will have a little foam and diluted starsan left over. My guess is that you will have no more than 10 mL of this left in the fermenter and this is likely a stretch, but 10 mL makes for easy math. This means that there is 2.38 mg of DDBSA and 7.93 mg of PA left in your ale pail. At this point you will dilute it again with 5 gallons of your wort which will turn into beer. This results in the new concentration of 0.000126 mg/mL of DDBSA and 0.000419 mg/mL of PA.

Based on this concentration you will drink 0.0596 mg of DDBSA and 0.198 mg of PA in each pint of beer that you just fermented.

Well if I keg my beer and follow the exact same dilutions to sanitize my keg I would have double the amount that I just listed above (i.e. 0.1192 mg DDBSA/pint and 0.396 mg PA/pint). What does this mean in terms of toxicity? The lowest LD50 (dose where 50% of animals will die) for DDBSA that I could find was for a mouse which is 50 mg/kg. If I would need this same dose where I have a 50% chance of death I would need 5000 mg (5 grams) of DDBSA. This about 41,900 pints of beer that I draw from my keg.

The lowest reported lethal dose of PA for a human is 200mg/kg, which for me it would be 20000 mg (20 grams). For me this is around 50,500 pints of beer from my keg.

As there are only 40 pints in a 5 gallon keg so you can drink your entire keg before you get to the reported lethal doses of the starsan agents. You would die from fluid over load (low sodium) or acute alcohol toxicity if you would drink your entire keg in a sitting before you have problems with the left over starsan.

If you leave less than 10 ml of diluted starsan your fermenter or keg then you need to proportionally increase the numbers of beer that you need to drink to reach your limit. If you leave 5 mL in your fermenter then I would need to drink twice the number of beers that I listed above…2mL’s in my fermenter then 5 times the number of beers that I listed above, etc., etc., etc.

Well I hope that this helps to calm any fears regarding the left over starsan solution in your fermenters/bottles/kegs. Now I need to start working on drinking some beers and get close to my limit.
 
Good to know. I always let the keg sit upside down for a while to get everything out. but there is always a bit of foam left..
 
HA, YOU'RE WRONG!!!!

I just finished #20 and I never started till 1 this aftgernoon. I'm still kiggin abd typion, si ur math is bugos/..........

ur, maybi it's the 10.2% RIS that's slurrrrrrin me speech??





So what part of the DDBSA and PA does the yeast consume as food? Does that increase the # of pints I can consume before i reach the PEL??

P.S. I like foam snake for some reason...., so faom is good!!
 
This math does not include any that is removed and consumed by the yeast as nutrition, or any that is neutralized by the change in the pH of the solution. This is really just a worst case scenario.
 
Ok, I love this. As Biochem I had already worked this out, wondering what would happen if I mixed up my starsan too strong and then drank some. It's great to see that someone else has done it too! On a side note, I agree that 10mL of liquid diluted sanitizer is a very high estimate, but like you said, worst case scenario.

P.S. I didn't bother checking your math, but I'm pretty sure I came up with something similar if you convert to volume of starsan drank at 2oz/5gal.
 
So what if you left a quart in the fermenting bucket when you added the wort? Is the taste gonna be noticeable, or should the yeast process most of it?
 
So what if you left a quart in the fermenting bucket when you added the wort? Is the taste gonna be noticeable, or should the yeast process most of it?

I'm sure that the yeast will process a lot if not all of the starsan. I don't know how much this occurs with the yeast but here are a few other posts where people did the same thing and they reported that the beer turned out fine.

I have done my share of bonehead things, too.

1. When I started brewing I used to ferment my beer in plastic buckets in a cubby-hole behind the furnace in my basement. It worked well to begin with (summer), and then I couldn't figure out why suddenly all my beer started tasting awful (winter when furnace was cycling in and out).

2. Racked my wort into the carboy before I had drained 2 - 3 quarts of Star San (beer turned out fine).

I have done many small minor mistakes..nothing too major.

One bone headed thing was adding beer to secondary with about 1/2 gallon of star san in it..turned out fine.

These are in the secondary when there is not even as much yeast as the primary so if you do it in the primary then I'm betting its just as safe.
 
Can the math explain what is inside of the bubbles? That is the reason I don't use star-san exclusively.
 
Can the math explain what is inside of the bubbles? That is the reason I don't use star-san exclusively.

I don't know about math but I think this is more of a physics answer. I am pretty sure that there is just regular air in the bubbles. The starsan is helping to increase the surface tension and allowing a bubble to form from just the plain air. The only time that you see a bubble is when you aerate the solution. If I am diluting my starsan from my sink's dishwasher hose (I have no idea what that is actually called) and submerge it below the water line there is no bubble creation. But if the water is splashing upon dilution then bubbles form.

The reason why no bubble forms with plain water is that water will not have enough suface tension to maintain a bubble. Here is the wikipedia link on soap bubbles which are likely very similar to the starsan bubbles.
 
I'm a little worried about using starsan. I just brewed my first batch ever (feels pretty good) and I used a counterflow chiller.

I have ocd. As in I check knobs (stove and door) and such and so my recollections are sometimes suspect.

I used the starsan to sanitized the tubing from the 15 gal stainless pot to the counter flow chiller, then of course the tubing from the chiller to the bucket.

I added water to flush out the starsan, but I don't know if I added it to some starsan that was already in the pot or if I poured the undrained excess starsan out of the pot and then added regular water. Anyway.

I then brewed my beer and when it came time to fill up the bucket I purged all the water from the tubing. What I noticed was that the color change from clear to wort was not distinct. So there is some worry that perhaps some starsan magically made it into brew.

Worst case scenario, if the whole counterflow chiller was full of starsan plus two 6 foot lengths of half inch and 3/8ths inch tubing were full of starsan at the "no rinse" concentration, what are my chances of getting ill. I did purge everything until the wort was a good dark brown but the slow color change makes me somewhat paranoid, thinking that perhaps some residual starsan had not been flushed out.

I realize that this is not such a logical worry, but if it was logical it wouldn't be ocd.

Thank you,

E. Lewis
 
I imagine the tubing and the counter flow chiller if filled to max with solution would be less than 1 liter. Its the bubba diesel chiller, and the tubing dimensions previously mentioned are of course the outer dimension... I believe.
 
Very interesting! I always wondered about the left over foam in my buckets and kegs.
 
Im sure this has been covered a million times, but can someone explain to me how Starsan "feeds" yeast? I think its kinda dumb when i read that every so often. Im sure in its diluted state that its pretty benign ad Im sure a little of it gets metabolized by yeast, but is it accurate to say Starsan feeds yeast cells?
 
Im sure this has been covered a million times, but can someone explain to me how Starsan "feeds" yeast? I think its kinda dumb when i read that every so often. Im sure in its diluted state that its pretty benign ad Im sure a little of it gets metabolized by yeast, but is it accurate to say Starsan feeds yeast cells?

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2491421/

PA is used in industrial wastewater treatment for the purpose of phosphate nutrient, like calcium to you and I. See the above link.
 
why did you have to resurrect this? This topic has the most boringest title on this planet of Earth.....yet I clicked on it anyway

better topic title: :goat: - A math explanation

edit: better yet: :goat: explanation - math
 
Back
Top