Sometimes regulators have left handed threads instead of the normal right handed. You might actually be tightening it rather than loosening it.
On tap: Recession Cider, Sterling Gold
Kegged: Sterling Gold, BCB Haus Pale Ale, BCB IPA (x2), Cream of 3 Crops
Primary: BCB Robust Porter (x2)
Secondary: Amarillo/Citra Pale ale
On Deck: Christmas Ale